The long-standing “black hole information paradox” has been completely solved

The “black hole information paradox” turns out (proven) to be a wrongly initiated dispute
------------------------------------------------ by Bingcheng Zhao

Related knowledge and explanation: (1) the current black hole theory is postulate-based feature, because it is based on Einstein’s general relativity that is postulate-based, so its real name should be postulate-based black hole theory (PBBHT); the black hole described and interpreted within the paradigm of PBBHT is referred to as postulate-based black hole. The two core concepts of PBBHT are Schwarzschild radius (i.e., event horizon) and singularity. (2) The black hole in the “black hole information paradox” refers to the black hole described and interpreted within the paradigm of PBBHT, so being referred to as postulate-based black hole.

Core reminding!!! Fact 1: PBBHT has been proven to be mechanistically thus essentially wrong ---- PBBHT turns out to be clearly and undeniably wrong (P. 535 ~ 541, 5.4, Ch.5B, reference #1; http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz76.blogspot.com/ ). Fact 2: Einstein’s general relativity has been proven to be mechanistically thus essentially wrong, due to it utterly skipping over the mechanism thus essence behind its describing phenomena via the “help” of a series of postulates and assumptions (P. 399 ~ 444, Ch.4A, reference #1; http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz74.blogspot.com/ ). Fact 3: quantum mechanics has been proven to be fundamentally, essentially and crucially wrong, utterly due to it unable to solve the fundamentally, essentially and crucially important problems in front of quantum physics (P. 346 ~ 359, 3.19, Ch.3E, reference #1; http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz75.blogspot.com/ ). These three proven thus undeniable facts will be tangibly helpful to digesting and accepting another proven fact: the so-called “black hole information paradox” turns out (has been proven) to be a wrongly initiated dispute ---- the central topic of 5.11.1, Ch.5C (P. 580 ~ 582, 5.11.1, Ch.5C, reference #1).

[*Four acronyms: (1) PBBHT = (the current) postulate-based black hole theory (P. 535 ~ 541, 5.4, Ch.5B, reference #1). (2) QM = quantum mechanics. (3) EPBGR = Einstein’s postulate-based general relativity (i.e., general relativity) ---- note, Einstein’s general relativity is based on a series of assumptions and postulates (e.g., the postulate of equivalence principle), so its real name should be Einstein’s postulate-based general relativity (EPBGR). (4) QFT = quantum field theory].


Completely solving the “black hole information paradox” by fully proving that the so-called “black hole information paradox” turns out to be a wrongly initiated dispute (P. 580 ~ 582, 5.11.1, Ch.5C, reference #1). Proving that the so-called “black hole information paradox” turns out to be a wrongly initiated dispute. (1) Both sides of the paradox rest on mechanistically thus essentially wrong foundations. The foundation of side A of the paradox (Drs. Hawking and Thorne) turns out to be the product of PBBHT plus quantum field theory (QFT), whereas both PBBHT and QFT have been proven to be mechanistically thus essentially wrong (P. 535 ~ 541, 5.4, Ch.5B, reference #1, http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz76.blogspot.com/ ; P. 804 ~ 809, 8.2, Ch.8A, reference #2, http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz82.blogspot.com/ ). The foundation of side B of the paradox (Dr. Preskill) turns out to be the product of wrong PBBHT plus the hypothesized correct quantum gravity theory (QGT), whereas the hypothesized quantum gravity has been proven not existing at all (P. 872 ~ 879, 9.5, Ch.9B, reference #2; http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bz38.blogspot.com/ ), needless to say correct QGT. (2) The creation of the “black hole information paradox” in itself turns out to be wrong. The creation of the paradox is virtually the consequence that both side A and side B of the paradox put QM and EPBGR together, whereas QM has been proven to be fundamentally, essentially and crucially wrong, utterly due to it unable to solve the fundamentally, essentially and crucially important problems in front of quantum physics (P. 346 ~ 359, 3.19, Ch.3E, reference #1; http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz75.blogspot.com/ ), and EPBGR has been proven to be mechanistically thus essentially wrong, due to it utterly skipping over the mechanism thus essence behind its describing phenomena via the “help” of a series of postulates and assumptions (P. 399 ~ 444, Ch.4A, reference #1; http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz74.blogspot.com/ ); as a matter of fact, QM and EPBGR are crucially incompatible, being a well-known and undeniable fact ---- furthermore, it has been proven that QM and EPBGR can never be unified (P. 848 ~ 858, 9.2, Ch.9A, reference #2; http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz84.blogspot.com/ ). All in all, there are more than sufficient evidences showing that the so-called “black hole information paradox” turns out to be a wrongly initiated dispute.


The key to understanding of the proven fact that the so-called “black hole information paradox” turns out (proven) to be a wrongly initiated dispute: (1) knowing of the proven fact that PBBHT turns out to be mechanistically thus essentially wrong ---- PBBHT is clearly and undeniably wrong (P. 535 ~ 541, 5.4, Ch.5B, reference #1; http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz76.blogspot.com/ ), simply because the so-called “black hole information paradox” is a byproduct of PBBHT. (2) Knowing of the newly established Mechanism-Revealed Black Hole Theory (MRBHT) (P. 541 ~ 553, 5.5 & 5.6, Ch.5B, reference #1, http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz28.blogspot.com/ ; http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz29.blogspot.com/ ), because the s-called “black hole information paradox” never appears at all within the paradigm of MRBHT.

What is the fundamentally profound implication of the proven fact that the so-called “black hole information paradox” turns out (proven) to be a wrongly initiated dispute: the long-standing “black hole information paradox” actually becomes a crucial clue indicating that general relativity and quantum mechanics may be mechanistically thus essentially wrong. In other words, the existence of the long-standing “black hole information paradox” is actually an important available clue helpful to digesting and accepting two proven facts: Einstein’s general relativity has been proven to be mechanistically thus essentially wrong (P. 399 ~ 444, Ch.4A, reference #1; http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz74.blogspot.com/ ); quantum mechanics has been proven to be fundamentally, essentially and crucially wrong (P. 346 ~ 359, 3.19, Ch.3E, reference #1; http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz75.blogspot.com/ ).

12 pieces of related information: (1) PBBHT has been proven to be mechanistically thus essentially wrong (P. 535 ~ 541, 5.4, Ch.5B, reference #1; http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz76.blogspot.com/ ). (2) General relativity has been proven to be mechanistically thus essentially wrong (P. 399 ~ 444, Ch.4A, reference #1; http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz74.blogspot.com/ ). (3) Quantum mechanics has been proven to be fundamentally, essentially and crucially wrong (P. 346 ~ 359, 3.19, Ch.3E, reference #1; http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz75.blogspot.com/ ). (4) Quantum field theory has been proven to be mechanistically thus essentially wrong (P. 804 ~ 809, 8.2, Ch.8A, reference #2; http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz82.blogspot.com/ ). (5) The hypothesized quantum gravity has been proven not existing at all (P. 872 ~ 879, 9.5, Ch.9B, reference #2; http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bz38.blogspot.com/ ). (6) It has been proven that quantum mechanics and general relativity can never be unified (P. 848 ~ 858, 9.2, Ch.9A, reference #2; http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz84.blogspot.com/ ). (7) Establishing and Verifying Mechanism-Revealed Gravitational Theory (P. 445 ~ 514, Ch.4B, reference #1; http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz20.blogspot.com/ ). (8) The newly established Mechanism-Revealed Black Hole Theory (P. 541 ~ 553, 5.5 & 5.6, Ch.5B, reference #1; http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz28.blogspot.com/ ), based on the newly established and verified mechanism-revealed physics. (9) Revealing the fundamental nature of Mechanism-Revealed Black Hole (P. 541 ~ 553, 5.5 & 5.6, Ch.5B, reference #1; http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz29.blogspot.com/ ), with the newly established Mechanism-Revealed Black Hole Theory. (10) The newly discovered law of object’s mass doing work (P. 93 ~ 109, Ch.1A, reference #1; http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz1.blogspot.com/ ). (11) Revealing the mechanism behind mass-energy equation (P. 114 ~ 118, 1.6, Ch.1B, reference #1; http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz2.blogspot.com/ ). (12) Mechanism-Revealed Physics, Bingcheng Zhao (http://mechanism-revealedphysics-bcz71.blogspot.com/ ).


Reference #1: 2009, Bingcheng Zhao, From Postulate-Based Modern Physics to Mechanism-Revealed Physics [Vol. 1(1/2)], ISBN: 978-1-4357-4913-9.
Reference #2: 2009, Bingcheng Zhao, From Postulate-Based Modern Physics to Mechanism-Revealed Physics [Vol. 2(2/2)], ISBN: 978-1-4357-5033-3.

Ph.D., Bingcheng Zhao,
The author of “From Postulate-Based Modern Physics to Mechanism-Revealed Physics”
1401 NE Merman Dr. Apt. 703, Pullman, WA 99163 USA.
Email: bingcheng.zhao@gmail.com